The Pains Of Being Pure At Heart
Perfect Right Now: A Slumberland Collection 2008-2010
Slumberland Records [2025]
“A time capsule of The Pains of Being Pure at Heart’s golden era—essential for fans and newcomers alike.”
Album Overview: Emerging from Brooklyn’s vibrant indie scene in the late 2000s, The Pains of Being Pure at Heart quickly built a reputation for channeling classic indie pop influences through a modern lens. Drawing from the melodic sensibilities of C86-era bands and early shoegaze, they made an instant impact with their Headphone Approved 2009 self-titled debut. Their jangly guitars and layers of fuzz captured ears and hearts, earning them a dedicated following. Perfect Right Now: A Slumberland Collection 2008-2010 gathers a selection of rare and sought-after tracks from their formative years, including B-sides from their debut-era singles, cuts from the Higher Than the Stars EP, and deep tracks from split releases. These songs encapsulate the band’s early songwriting style, where boundless enthusiasm met a deep love for classic indie pop.
Musical Style: The Pains of Being Pure at Heart blend shimmering guitars, propulsive rhythms, and heartfelt melodies into an irresistible mix of indie pop and shoegaze. Their early sound balances delicate vocals with waves of distortion, creating a dynamic interplay between intimacy and energy. They masterfully combine noise and melody, evoking nostalgia without feeling derivative.
Evolution of Sound: While their early recordings lean into a lo-fi, DIY aesthetic, this collection reveals a growing ambition. Tracks like the final “Say No to Love” hint at the more polished approach they’d adopt later, while others capture the raw energy of their scrappy beginnings. Across these songs, you can hear a band refining their craft with a burning spirit.
Artists with Similar Fire: If you’re drawn to The Pains of Being Pure at Heart’s dreamy yet noisy indie pop, check out The Field Mice, Black Tambourine, Los Campesinos!, and The Aislers Set. Their hazy, feedback-laden moments also align with bands like A Sunny Day in Glasgow and Alvvays, bridging classic jangle pop with modern dream pop—much like Belle & Sebastian but with a fuzzier edge.
Pivotal Tracks: “Kurt Cobain’s Cardigan,” from an early 7″ split with The Parallelograms, highlights the band’s knack for crafting instantly memorable hooks with a playful edge. The self-titled “The Pains of Being Pure at Heart” remains a defining statement of their early sound. “Ramona,” the B-side to “Young Adult Friction,” leans further into shoegaze, drenching its melody in a catchy vapor haze. Closing track “Say No to Love” stands out as a turning point, showcasing a more refined take on their signature sound. These tracks, along with the rest of the compilation, have remained fan favorites, their charm lasting well beyond their initial release.
Lyrical Strength: The band’s lyrics reflect youthful longing, fleeting moments, and the emotional highs and lows of adolescence and early adulthood. There’s a sincerity in their words, even when wrapped in layers of fuzz and reverb. Their songs capture the excitement, uncertainty, and heartache of growing up, making them both deeply personal and universally relatable.
Final Groove: Perfect Right Now is more than a compilation—it’s a time capsule of a band at their most eager and earnest, blending scrappy indie pop with shoegaze textures. These tracks showcase The Pains of Being Pure at Heart’s ability to craft songs that feel both immediate and timeless. Whether you’re rediscovering them or hearing these songs for the first time, this collection serves as a reminder of their lasting impact. With their blend of nostalgia and fresh energy, it’s easy to see why their music still resonates—and why their influence will continue shaping indie pop for years to come.
THE PAINS OF BEING PURE AT HEART REVIEW HISTORY
The Echo of Pleasure (2017) / Days Of Abandon (2014)
THE PAINS OF BEING PURE AT HEART LINKS
Website | Facebook | Bluesky | Instagram | Bandcamp | Slumberland Records
- The Tubs: Cotton Crown [Album Review] - March 12, 2025
- Cheekface: Middle Spoon [Album Review] - March 4, 2025
- Nervous Verbs: Pony Coughing [Album Review] - February 27, 2025